Praised Into a Bubble: How Compliments Cripple a Writer’s Growth
In many writing spaces—especially smaller, local, or peer-driven ones—praise is abundant. Writers cheer each other on with phrases like “You did great!” or “So good!” and “Love it!” Comments flood in with heart emojis and words of affirmation. And in many ways, it’s beautiful. Writing is such a vulnerable act, and having people affirm your work can be encouraging. Especially for beginners, a little kindness can go a long way.
But there’s a problem when praise becomes the default response—when it’s automatic, excessive, and disconnected from actual substance. That’s when it starts to create a bubble—an emotional echo chamber where a writer feels consistently validated but never challenged. Inside that bubble, it becomes harder to see flaws, hear honest critique, or even recognize when a piece isn’t working. The praise becomes a cushion. And cushions don’t sharpen you.
Over time, this constant affirmation can cripple growth. I’ve seen it firsthand—stories that are polished on the surface but emotionally hollow. Stories that play it safe. That resolve too neatly. That avoid depth, tension, or discomfort. And yet, they get celebrated by friends, liked by peers, even published in communities that don’t necessarily vet for quality. That kind of validation, while flattering, builds false confidence. The writer begins to believe they’ve already “arrived” when, in truth, they’ve barely begun.
This isn’t to say praise is bad. Of course not. We all need encouragement—especially when we’re doubting ourselves or starting out. But praise without honesty is empty. And when it becomes too frequent or too soft, it sedates the hunger to improve. It makes a writer chase likes instead of growth. Approval instead of truth.
On the flip side, real support often looks like discomfort. It’s someone telling you, “This part doesn’t land.” Or “I think you’re holding back.” Or even, “You can go deeper than this.” It’s feedback that stings a little—but lingers. And that lingering? That’s where the growth begins.
I say all this as someone who’s both given and received feedback over the years. I’ve experienced the bubble. I’ve seen how easy it is to stay there, where everyone smiles and claps, but no one really gets better. And I’ve also seen what happens when someone breaks out of that bubble—when they meet a mentor, editor, or peer who doesn’t flatter, but reflects. Someone who holds up a mirror, not a trophy.
If you’re a writer reading this: don’t fear critique. Don’t settle for being praised. Ask people what didn’t work. Ask for the hard truths. Be willing to sit with the sting. That sting will make you stronger than any hundred compliments ever could.
And if you’re someone giving feedback: be kind, yes. But don’t withhold honesty for the sake of politeness. Writers don’t need to be coddled. They need to be challenged—by someone who believes in their potential enough to say, “You can do better.”
Because in the end, the goal isn’t to be endlessly praised.
It’s to become the kind of writer who doesn’t need the bubble at all.
Subscribe to our Substacks for ✨ honest reflections, spicy prompts, and behind-the-scenes rants:
– Indie From the Islands by Mariel (Publishing brain & emotional backbone)
– Daydreams for Breakfast by Pasta (Word witch & chaos gremlin)
Got questions, ideas, or undying affection for our team? 👀
We accept all forms of communication—especially dramatic ones.
hello@alontala.com
New here? Start with “What We’re Really Doing Here” and get to know why AlònTala was never meant to be ordinary.
